Check the Batch
Class ITerminated in FDA datasetRecall initiated Apr 13, 2015

Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap…

Recalling firm: Garber Ice Cream Company Inc

Why it was recalled

Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen).

Historical recall record. This is not a new recall announcement. “Terminated” describes the FDA recall process; it does not certify that an individual package is safe. FDA termination date: May 2, 2016.

Check your package

Compare the exact product and package details with the label you have.

ProductGarber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap of 3. #1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles
UPC028387600682

FDA code information

#1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles UPC# 0-28387-60068-2

Match the product, package size, and code together. A missing match does not guarantee safety.

Full FDA record and distribution details

Original product description

Garber's Old Fashioned Ice cream, Birthday Cake Flavored 1.75 quarts, packed in a shrink wrap of 3. #1 lot of 211/ 3 pk produced on 12/12/13 expires on 12/12/14 #2 lot of 451/3 pk produced on 3/31/14 expires 3/31/15 #3 lot of 454/3 pk produced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles

Extracted codes and context

TypeCode / valueContext
UPC028387600682ced on 11/5 14 expires on 11/5/15 1116 (three packs) = 3348 singles UPC# 0-28387-60068-2

Original FDA recall reason

Firm voluntarily recalling 56 oz. Birthday Cake Ice cream due to adding the wrong ingredient into cake. (eggs added to cake) (undeclared egg allergen).

Recall details

Recall number
F-2440-2015
Event ID
71221
FDA status
Terminated
Initiated
Apr 13, 2015
Reported
Jun 24, 2015
Classified
Jun 12, 2015
Terminated
May 2, 2016
Quantity
2427 Distributed. 921 still in house
Location
Winchester, VA, United States
Initiation type
Voluntary: Firm initiated
Notification
Other

Where it was distributed

According to firm the distribution pattern is Virginia, West Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Maryland

FDA source record · F-2440-2015

Data updated September 16, 2026. View official FDA data ↗

Follow official FDA and manufacturer guidance.